The main course on United's Polaris service from Honolulu (HNL) to Chicago O'Hare (ORD) didn't arrive until roughly an hour after takeoff - a detail Jeb Brooks noted as the most concrete measure of how the flight unfolded (4:17). The delay framed a broader comparison: Brooks and his travel companion Suzanne flew both Delta One on the MSP–HNL route aboard an Airbus A330, then United Polaris on the HNL–ORD return on a Boeing 787 Dreamliner, and the two flights did not come out equal (0:28, 10:05).

Delta One: Minneapolis to Honolulu

The outbound leg departed Minneapolis-Saint Paul International Airport (MSP) on Delta Air Lines' A330 in Delta One, the carrier's long-haul business class cabin. Before boarding, the pair visited the Delta Sky Club at MSP. Suzanne's assessment was direct (1:10):

“This is a great club.”
— Suzanne1:10

Brooks has covered Delta Sky Clubs extensively; when he surveyed more than 50 U.S. airport lounges earlier this year, he ranked the Delta 1 Lounge as the best in the country. The MSP club drew a simpler but positive reaction from Suzanne before the Hawaii flight.

In the air, the crew drew the most praise. After landing in Honolulu, Suzanne ranked service above every other element of the Delta One experience (7:09):

“I got to say the service was the best part of the flight for sure.”
— Suzanne7:09

The seat earned a more measured response. Suzanne called it comfortble but acknowledged its age (7:18):

“The seat a little bit old, a little bit outdated, but still plenty comfortable.”
— Suzanne7:18

On catering, Suzanne set a measured baseline: "The food was okay and what I would have expected for an international flight in business class" (7:22). That framing, adequate rather than impressive, would become the standard against which the United leg was measured.

United Polaris: Honolulu to Chicago O'Hare

The return flight operated on a United 787 Dreamliner in United Polaris business class, departing Honolulu for Chicago O'Hare (ORD). The meal service timing was the first concrete point of friction: the main course arrived approximately one hour after takeoff. Whether that gap reflects a deliberate service sequence or a slower galley operation, Brooks logged it as a notable lag.

The crew was not the problem. Brooks described the flight attendants as friendly and efficient, but the comparison to the Minneapolis-based Delta crew was unfavorable (17:18):

“The crew was friendly and efficient, but they couldn't match up to the spectacular Minneapolis based Delta crew we had.”
— Jeb Brooks17:19

Brooks has put United's premium cabin under scrutiny before. In an earlier review of United's 767 business class service between San Francisco and JFK, he gave the product 20 out of 25 stars — a solid but not exceptional score. The Polaris product on the Honolulu departure did not appear to improve on that impression.

The "First Class" Label

The episode's title, "The TRUTH About 'FIRST CLASS' to Hawaii", points at a recurring issue Brooks has raised across multiple comparisons, which is that domestic and Hawaii-route "first class" branding often describes what is practically a business class seat. When he ranked U.S. domestic first class cabins across American, Delta, and United, he found Delta's catering the strongest of the three but criticized the bland food on United. The Hawaii comparison follows a similar pattern, with Delta's crew and overall product edging out United's, while catering on both flights landed in the "acceptable" range rather than anything stronger.

Brooks has also noted the gap between marketing language and actual product on domestic routes before. In his examination of basic economy across all three major carriers, he found Delta's service the most consistent. That consistency appears to hold on the Hawaii corridor, at least on this pairing.

The overall verdict from both travelers was mixed on each product individually, but directional. Delta's Minneapolis crew set a benchmark the United Polaris crew did not reach, the Delta seat was older but comfortable, and United's meal pacing added a minor but measurable friction point. Neither flight failed; one simply performed better than the other on the metrics Brooks and Suzanne applied.