Forty-five minutes into a short intra-European hop from Munich Airport (MUC) to Helsinki Airport (HEL) aboard a Finnair Airbus A350, Josh Cahill received his meal: potato and chicken, with no alternative on offer. For a business class ticket, the absence of any menu choice is the kind of detail that tends to define the overall impression of a short-haul premium product, regardless of how good the hardware is.
The Seat: A Genuine Surprise
Cahill's first impression of Finnair's new business class seat was straightforwardly positive. He described it as "spacious, clean, and feels private" (3:14) - language that suggests the product holds up at first glance, not just in press photography. The A350 cabin on this Munich–Helsinki service offered direct aisle access, a feature that has become a baseline expectation on long-haul business class but remains far from universal on short European routes.
When the seat was reclined to its fully flat position, Cahill noted (10:01) that he was pleasantly surprised by the amount of space. That reaction carries some weight given the route: Munich to Helsinki is roughly two and a half hours, a sector where airlines frequently deploy long-haul aircraft without adjusting the product to match. The seat, in Cahill's assessment, did not feel like a compromise.
“I feel like the seat is a lot more flexible than people think it is and it gives you enough space.”
That comment came after Cahill had worked through the seat's various configurations during the flight, and it reads as a direct response to the controversy the seat has attracted online. The "most controversial seat in aviation" framing in the episode title is a nod to the debate that has surrounded Finnair's business class layout, which some travellers have criticised for its dimensions and positioning. Cahill's verdict, based on time actually spent in it, is that the criticism is overstated.
Crew and Boarding
Boarding started just before the scheduled departure time (8:17), which on a short European sector leaves little margin for the kind of pre-departure service that distinguishes business class from a curtained-off economy row. Cahill's read on the crew was unambiguous: he said (2:30) they were "super friendly and seemed happy to have me aboard". That is a brief but consistent note — attentive cabin staff on a sector where crews are often simply managing a rapid turnaround.
Catering: The Persistent Weak Point
The single meal option, hot potato and chicken, served around the 45-minute mark (5:28), is the clearest gap in an otherwise solid product. On a sub-three-hour flight, there is limited time for elaborate catering, but the absence of any alternative is a meaningful shortcoming at the business class price point. Cahill flagged it as a negative, and the criticism is straightforward: choice, even a modest one, is a reasonable expectation when a passenger has paid a premium fare.
This is not the first time Cahill has found Finnair's catering wanting. In earlier coverage of a Finnair business class product, he described the experience as feeling "more like premium economy in business", a mixed verdict that praised the service while criticising the food offering as budget-oriented. The MUC–HEL flight suggests that gap has not been closed, at least on shorter intra-European sectors.
Munich has featured in Cahill's reviews before, though in a different context. When he reviewed Lufthansa's new business class out of MUC, he noted that the German carrier had finally introduced direct aisle access, while observing it had taken considerably longer than rival airlines to do so. The comparison is instructive: Finnair's A350 product, by contrast, does not appear to be playing catch-up on the hardware side.
Overall Assessment
Cahill concluded that Finnair is "a fantastic product that differentiates itself from the competition", a verdict that holds up when the seat quality and crew are weighed against the catering shortfall. The A350 cabin on this route delivers on the hardware: the seat is genuinely spacious, the privacy is real, and the crew performance was consistent. What Finnair has not resolved, at least on this Munich–Helsinki service, is whether a single hot meal option is sufficient to justify the business class fare on a short European sector. For passengers whose priority is the seat and the sleep, the answer may well be yes. For those who expect a full premium catering experience on any flight with a business class cabin, the answer is less clear.



